• Quick and easy returns
  • Seamless shopping
  • Quick and easy returns
  • Seamless shopping
0,00 pln 0

Basket

No products in the basket.

  • Quick and easy returns
  • Seamless shopping
News

Starch adhesive vs methylcellulose adhesive – which to choose for paper preservation?

The correct choice of adhesive for paper conservation depends on the type of substrate, the type of damage, and the intended treatment. Starch adhesive and methylcellulose are among the most commonly used aqueous adhesives for paper conservation. The possibility of their removal and the risk to the object depend on the specific material and the sensitivity of the paper to water. Learn the most important information about the combination of reversible conservation adhesives – methylcellulose and starch. 

What are the differences between starch adhesive for introligation and methylcellulose adhesive?

Starch glue is obtained from plant starch and has long been used in the preservation of paper and in introligation. Methylcellulose is an ester of cellulose available in powder form. The method of its preparation depends on the specific product; the reaction of both adhesives depends, among other things, on the raw material, purity, and water used, so it is not necessary to assume a neutral pH in advance.

Differences between starch adhesive and methylcellulose include the strength and flexibility of the bond, the contraction of the adhesive layer, and the working time. Starch adhesive usually provides a stronger bond than methylcellulose alone, but the properties depend on the type of adhesive, concentration, and substrate.

Both glues are water-sensitive: their reversibility does not mean that they can always be removed without risk to the paper and the dyes.

What properties does starch glue have?

The starch adhesive is prepared by heating the starch with water until it reaches a consistency suitable for the intended procedure. The recipe and proportions depend on the type of starch, the required viscosity, and the working technique. After preparation, the paste can be strained through a sieve to remove any lumps.

Basic properties of starch adhesive:

  • usually a stronger connection than when using the me itselftylocellulose; the effect depends on the formulation, concentration and medium,
  • plant origin; The pH is not guaranteed by the method of preparation alone and depends on the ingredients used and the water used.,
  • water-based adhesive increases the moisture content of the substrate; excessive water or uneven drying can deform the paper,
  • The working time depends on the concentration, amount of adhesive, substrate and drying conditions; it is worth checking it before the procedure,
  • the possibility of adjusting the consistency by diluting with water.

Adhesive starch is used, among other things, to fix repair papers when filling in gaps and to glue torn areas together. 

The conditions and storage time of the paste depend on the recipe, the hygiene of preparation and temperature; laboratory procedures must be followed and the adhesive must be discarded if signs of deterioration appear.

When is it worth choosing methylcellulose?

Methylcellulose can be chosen when a flexible adhesive layer is needed or when a longer working time is required. Its properties depend on the type of product, the concentration and the amount of moisture introduced; both starch adhesive and methylcellulose can deform the sensitive paper.

It should not be assumed that all methylcellulose has a neutral pH or that it is resistant to storage conditions. It is hygroscopic and soluble in water, and its durability depends on the species and conditions.

There is no basis for considering the lack of starch itself to be a guarantee of protecting the object from mold or bacteria.

Applications of methylcellulose in paper conservation:

  • selected consolidation treatments for weakened paper, after evaluating its reaction to moisture; the aqueous solution can cause deformation,
  • selected repairs of paper with graphics or watercolor – only after checking the media's sensitivity to water and choosing a method to limit its contact with the object,
  • strengthening weakened areas of the paper before further treatments,
  • use when separating laminated cards.

Methylcellulose is prepared according to the instructions for the specific product type.

Some products are dispersed in hot water and then cooled to allow complete hydration; other procedures depend on the parameters of the particular cellulose ether. The preparation time and the obtaining of a homogeneous gel also depend on the product.

Which glue works best for various paper repairs?

The answer depends on three factors:

  • type of paper,
  • the nature of the damage and
  • the required strength of the connection.

The thickness of the paper can influence the choice of adhesive, but it does not by itself dictate the choice. Starch adhesive usually forms a stronger bond, and methylcellulose can provide a more flexible layer.

With thin papers and delicate objects, both adhesives can introduce moisture and cause deformation; the decision is made after taking into account the structure, media, condition of the object, and the requirements of the procedure.

Practical summary:

  • filling in gaps in thick paper: starch glue,
  • adhesion of cracks in thin graphics: methylcellulose,
  • strengthening the spine of the fixture: adhesive glue,
  • consolidation of fragile cards before digitalization: methylcellulose,
  • bonding Japanese papers with fillers: methylcellulose or a mixture of both adhesives,
  • Intriguing work on historical settings: starch glue.

In some treatments, mixtures of starch glue and methylcellulose are used to change their working properties. The effect depends on the proportions, concentration, and application; it should not be assumed that each mixture produces the same intermediate parameters.

How to prepare and apply conservation adhesives?

Proper preparation of the adhesive has the same effect on the result of the work as its selection. Too thick adhesive does not penetrate the paper structure; too thin adhesive over-moistsens it.

Preparation of the starch adhesive step by step:

  • choose the proportions of starch and water according to the type of starch, the required viscosity, and the procedure used; the values are not universal;,
  • mix the starch with a small amount of cold water to avoid lumps,
  • heat the mixture according to the recipe, stirring constantly until the starch has gelatinized and the paste has reached the required consistency,
  • cool and strain through a sieve,
  • Store in a clean, closed container in accordance with the laboratory procedure; there is no expiration date for each recipe, and discard any glue with signs of spoilage.

Preparation of methylcellulose:

  • add the powder to cold distilled water in the proportion recommended by the manufacturer,
  • stir until the powder is evenly distributed,
  • Leave to fully dissolve for the time indicated for the product; check that the solution is homogeneous;,
  • Store in a clean, tightly closed container in accordance with the laboratory procedure and the manufacturer's recommendations; do not assume a universal shelf life.

The method of application depends on the repair structure and the sensitivity of the object. The adhesive can be applied to the repair paper or locally to the object – after preliminary assessment of the risk of moisture ingress.

The amount of adhesive, the pressure, and the drying method are chosen according to the specific procedure; not every repair should be performed by directly applying adhesive to the surface or drying it under load.

How to choose glue for a specific type of paper and damage?

The decision to choose a reversible curing adhesive should take into account several parameters simultaneously.

The weight and structure of the paper are the first point of assessment. Thin papers are more prone to wrinkling under the influence of moisture. With them, methylcellulose or very rare starch glue limits the risk of deformation. Thick and rigid papers tolerate higher concentrations of starch glue.

The type of damage determines the required bond strength. Minor tears only require consolidation, so methylcellulose is perfectly sufficient. Cracks in the spine of the frame or torn cards require a stronger adhesive that will provide a starch adhesive.

The condition of the object affects the choice of tool. Fragile, fragile cards require consolidation with methylcellulose first before proceeding with proper repair. Attempting to glue fragile paper without prior reinforcement can deepen the damage.

Storage conditions after preservation are important when choosing a glue. Materials exposed to fluctuations in humidity are better protected by methylcellulose because its bond is more flexible and less sensitive to climate changes. Starch-based glue in a high-humidity environment may lose part of its adhesive strength or become a food source for microorganisms.

An attempt on similar paper can be used to preliminary assess the adhesive, but it does not replace the testing of the sensitivity of the original paper and media. For objects with ink, paint, or other colored layers, their reaction to water and adhesive must be evaluated before the treatment. Starch and methylcellulose adhesives have different properties; the choice depends on the requirements of the specific repair, not on the general hierarchy of one adhesive over another.

Starch adhesive vs methylcellulose adhesive – FAQ

  • Which glue creates a stronger bond?

Usually, starch glue works well, although the effect depends on the recipe, concentration and substrate.

  • When is it worth choosing methylcellulose?

When a flexible layer is needed, slight shrinkage after drying or longer working time.

  • Do starch glue and methylcellulose have a neutral pH?

This should not be assumed. The reaction depends, among other things, on the raw material, purity and the water used.

  • Can both glues be mixed together?

Yes, their mixtures are used in some treatments. Their properties depend on the proportions, concentration, and application.

Sign up for the Newsletter

And receive Free eBook!
Agreement*